Modular housing off Tubber Lane
- Paul Gogarty TD
- May 22, 2024
- 16 min read
Updated: May 22, 2024
(This update 22nd May replaces updates on 28/02/24, 26/02/24 and earlier updates January 2024 and October 2023 (x4). Further updates will be provided as information becomes available)
Update 22nd May
We had our site visit earlier this month and got to see the inside of the units. See video below and photos.
We also received a presentation from the OPW about the rollout of the programme and potential other uses. This is attached here for your convenience:
Current estimates are that the first arrivals will be accommodated at this location later in June. As I mentioned in the video, while the housing provision is first class, the ancillary service provision is poor and there is no joined up thinking among agencies, let alone movement from the Department of Education in terms of using the additional population from this site to help fast-track school provision for the wider Adamstown area.
27th February Update
We know now that work on the 132 modular homes under the Office of Public Works should be complete on the site at the end of April with arrivals beginning, on a phased basis, in May.
The Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth had said it will be in contact with agencies to support planning of service delivery in the coming weeks. I asked for further details on medical and childcare/educational provision, on measures to improve road sweeping schedules and on screening to minimise the effect of lighting on existing homes in Tubber Lane.
I got replies yesterday 27th February to a number of queries. The replies are listed below:
Site visit
You indicated that it may be possible for elected members to visit the site. I would appreciate an opportunity to do this, hopefully when one of the units is fully constructed.
"Will co – ordinate a visit when the site is ready for occupation which is likely to be towards the end of April".
On-site provision of services for residents
There has been no indication as of yet what services will be available for residents on the actual site itself. For example, will there be a room and timeslots made available for visits by GPs and public health nurses? Will there be on-site childcare? Will there be a shop or indoor café/recreation area? And finally, by what stage will be known how many children in various age groups will require school accommodation the following September?
"There are no onsite services. This development is envisaged as other housing developments and will use local services, a factor which is critical for integration.
"I am contacting education, health and other services to assist with planning for these arrivals. The REALT co – ordinator is already linking in with International Organisation for Migration regarding ages of children etc for schools.
"Allocation is taking place currently".
I had mentioned before at the meeting in Adamstown community centre that would need to be additional resourcing put into school places at primary and second level. Has there been any further engagement from the Department of education? In particular, in advance of the construction of the expanded 32 classroom Adamstown Castle Educate Together National School, has any provision been made for the opening of a new junior infants classroom on this site, or is there space available in the existing 16 classroom school?
"Education are aware of new arrivals and we currently working with REALT co – ordinator."
There is also the issue of primary care services. No doubt this development, even with some on-site provision, will place additional pressure locally in terms of healthcare. In this respect, it is crucial that the HSE opens up the primary healthcare centre opposite The Crossings in Adamstown SDZ. Has your department received any communications in this regard?
"I have received no communication but will be engaging with HSE at national and local level."
Disruption caused by construction
While there have been intermittent efforts to cleanse the adjacent roads, I have received ongoing complaints about muck on the Celbridge link road. Could you get the OPW to insist that Sisk provides more resources for regular cleansing and maintenance of dirt caused by its vehicles?
"I will bring to OPW attention.
Separate to this, at the Area Committee meeting on 27th February, my Independent colleague Cllr Liona O'Toole had a motion on the agenda seeking a further meeting with the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth (DCEDIY) and the Office of Public Works. I mentioned the above response I had got in terms of the lack of clarity regarding healthcare and education and she was happy for her motion to be amended to add in an invitation to the Department of Education and the Department of Health. The motion as amended was passed but there are no guarantees that these sections will engage directly given previous responses. But it is important to get relevant information and for the local community to be kept up to date on this matters.
Any further information in relation to any of the above will be posted here when it becomes available.
---
What is proposed?
We received official confirmation in January that the original proposal to build 136 two-bedroom modular homes on the site had been amended slightly to 120 single storey, 2 bed homes and 12 x 2 storey 3 bed homes, giving a revised total of 132 homes. This news came some time after the changes were noticed on the ground, however it was good to get the official update, albeit belatedly.
The OPW said: "As part of the programme and to further explore broader possibilities for these units OPW are installing a small number of two storey houses on the site. A short video of their installation which you may find interesting will be forwarded to you". The video, first made in December, did not come through the SDCC servers and we have been provided a pdf instead on the 12 larger homes which can be viewed below:
The OPW also added: "Whilst, the homes are being delivered as part of the Ukrainian rapid delivery programme and will house those fleeing the war in Ukraine, this 2 storey model could provide a new model for delivery of family sized homes across the country."
We were originally told at a briefing in July that the number of properties would potentially be in the region of 100 but possibly up to 140, so this figure is still within the original projections. The OPW had said 136 two-beds would accommodate approximately 544 people in family units of four, so the maths will not have changed much in the new configuration, but it clearly allows for more flexibility.
What disruption will the works cause?
There will be some noise and localised traffic and some residents have already commented on this. However unlike the building works over many years in Adamstown SDZ, the housing here is manufactured off-site and transported in, meaning that the disruption levels will be much lower than with normal housing development. It was an early concern that the main traffic for the site would be along the semi-rural Tubber Lane, but construction access and the final site access has now been directed towards the larger Celbridge Link Road.
Did these houses require rezoning or any type of vote by Councillors?
This is agricultural land not zoned for housing and housing is only permitted here under emergency legislation that is scheduled to last for three years. The Government is obliged under EU law to provide accommodation to people under the Temporary Protective Directive (European Council Directive 2001/55EC), in this case those fleeing the conflict in Ukraine. My understanding is that funding is provided under a common EU framework to cover these costs (which Ireland would contribute to).
What will the housing look like?
The photographs here show the layout of the site, the type of units proposed in situ and an example of the houses currently being lifted in. Reminder - see pdf in "What is proposed" section for details on the 2 storey houses.
Pre-fabricated units already on the site before finishing
Indicative layout of site
Architect's impression of what housing will look like
Is the housing good quality?
The DCEDIY says that these Rapid Build homes will be "energy efficient and durable and the sites will be developed in a way that enhances the local area". The site will have roads, footpaths, street lighting, community facilities, including green spaces, fully in line with national guidance. The Department says it will also provide for the management and maintenance of the homes and site.
There's more on the 2-bed single storey design from this presentation given in June 2023, which although it references Backweston, focuses mainly on the type of housing being rolled out nationally:
Is the housing suitable for long term use?
The OPW says that the housing is so high-quality and well-insulated that it has a lifespan of 60 years. However the fact that most of the housing is 2-bed means that it is not necessarily suitable for accommodating growing families long term and is probably best used for emergency accommodation for those in need of housing until they can get permanent housing and potentially could be used as permanent housing in the right location for smaller family units, for couples, or as sheltered housing. It would be a waste not to use it into the future, the question is where.
Who will manage the housing estate?
We were told on 10th October that this development will be managed by Tuath Housing, an Approved Housing Body that manages a number of social housing projects around the country.
What will happen after three years? [Latest commentary 28/02/24]
The official line is that the "use of Rapid Build Homes to temporarily house people fleeing Ukraine allows the Government to pilot this type of accommodation to determine the best use of the planned units into the future. It will be possible then to see if the units are suitable for social housing, student accommodation or for other uses".
However the reality is that nobody can say as of now. The Government could extend emergency legislation. However without further emergency legislation this housing could not stay in situ once it lapses. The Development Plan would need to be altered by a vote of Councillors to change the zoning of the land to residential, or else the housing would have to be redesignated as social housing. Normally a social housing plan requires a public consultation phase and a vote of Councillors, but from 2023 until later 2024 the Government has put in place plans to fast-track social housing without it going to a "Part 8" vote. If I did have a vote I would have serious concerns long term about any type of permanent housing at this site, private or public. Especially with 8-11,000 homes planned in Clonburris and the fact that successive Governments have let the centre of Dublin city disintegrate when it needs revitalisation and a population influx close to the city centre.
Can more modular housing be added?
My understanding is that there is not much more land available here if the OPW wanted, but to be clear, there's nothing to stop the Government from adding emergency housing at this location or elsewhere if there is legislation to back it up. But the arguments about this area go beyond temporary plans into whether it is actually suitable for development beyond that time.
There has always been the argument about the need to retain a rural buffer between Lucan and Leixlip and Celbridge. But in the context of a housing crisis where we need to get as much housing as possible ASAP there is still the factor that any long term housing also needs proper facilities and infrastructure and should be dealt with as part of a Strategic Development Zone-type plan. Adamstown SDZ has been rolled out with amenities alongside. Piecemeal development is not good planning long term.
To reiterate, if I had a vote on a housing plan at this location I would vote against it, unless the Adamstown SDZ was extended, but this should not be even considered for extending while there are thousands of houses to go. Efforts to get land adjacent to the SDZ rezoned as residential were voted down by myself and others in the last development plan, so as of now we are talking an emergency accommodation time extension, emergency social housing time extension, or regular social housing needing a vote of Councillors, because this can go on land not designated residential. To me, in planning terms, there is no difference. Housing needs amenities and infrastructure, private or public. So I always oppose housing plans without proper consideration for facilities alongside.
What are the main current issues associated with this site?
There are a number of issues. Firstly the need to ensure that those living in the emergency accommodation have enough amenities on site and are able to access nearby larger retail outlets like Lidl Shackleton through as direct a route as possible, given that this will be a 20-24 minute round trip walking. They need access to school places and healthcare and other community amenities. Some may be provided on-site, but lots won't [Update 28th February 2024... it's clear now that no healthcare or education will be provided on-site - it's being added into the housing mix, which places the responsibility on the agencies to ensure that this population and the existing residents of Adamstown get the services required asap].
Secondly, local residents living in the immediate area need traffic disruption kept to a minimum and SDCC needs to consider putting additional measures in place.
Lastly - and I've no doubt that the people of Adamstown and the wider Lucan area will give the Ukrainian families a very warm welcome - the State and its agencies need to ensure that residents living in the wider Adamstown area, especially those in the newer estates, are not disadvantaged. By this I mean, with pressure already coming on school places and a shortage of childcare facilities and GP services, that the Minister at the DCEDIY, the Minister for Education and the Minister for Health will all need to ensure that delivery of services to Adamstown is ramped up.
I previously posted in updates in Adamstown that from a school perspective, this could be a "win-win", in that the 32-classroom school already granted permission at Tandy's Lane, but not due to open until 2026, could potentially open earlier as a result of the Ukrainian children that will arrive here from April 2024.
There is already pressure on places with estates like Hallwell, Gandon and more recent developments not being placed in the catchment area of schools geographically adjacent such as Scoil Mhuire. When the Ukrainian children, along with some of the children currently at the emergency homeless accommodation in Finnstown Castle Hotel, are taken into consideration, the population increase should definitely be a "tipping point" to warrant at least one junior infants class opening up on the new site or at a temporary location pending the permanent building being constructed.
Site location and elevation drawings above and below of what the finalised 32-classroom primary school building off Tandy's Lane will look like when completed. Irrespective of the tender process for the new building, the school needs to open asap in a temporary building
A major additional challenge will be childcare places, slow to roll out in Adamstown. As this is largely generated by the private sector, but funded by Government for ECCE and other schemes, there may be a need for a state or agency-run facility on the site itself.
Healthcare and access to GPs will also be crucial. As of now we have discussions ongoing between Quintain and the HSE regarding the use of the landmark building on Adamstown Boulevard, opposite The Crossings, for use as a Primary Care Centre. With challenges facing private GP practices in finding suitable locations in Adamstown SDZ, the opening of the primary care facility, which should have GP and public health nurse services will be crucial. Again, the hope is that the Ukrainian arrivals will help speed up the delivery here and this is something else I continue to chase up.
Proposed location of Primary Health Care Centre
However we need to keep up the pressure. This is why the information briefing session on the 10th of October was useful.
Report on public information briefing on Tuesday, October 10th
An informational event with display boards and OPW/DECDIY staff on hand to answer questions was held in Adamstown Community and Youth Centre on 10th October last . Thanks to SDCC staff for facilitating.
An earlier version of this article mentioned the meeting and urged residents to attend. Approximately 30 people turned up at various stages, with the largest number from Hallwell, the estate closest to the emergency accommodation. Most of those present came between 7:30and 8:30pm when the one-to-one format turned into a larger discussion, with many questions asked and lots of opinions expressed.
An example of the display boards at the meeting
A number of residents conveyed unhappiness at the slow release of information and/or lack of consultation, with one resident saying that he had heard something as far back as March but detailed information was a long time coming.
Another person said: “Today is the first day I heard of it. Transparency and communication were absent here. The point is we welcome people but this is not a good starting point and that’s poor social policy.”
Another comment described the plan as “an experiment and we are participating without consent”.
There were more concerns expressed about “secrecy” but the team said it was not deliberate secrecy.
Residents largely accepted, whether they are happy or not with this proposal, that it is permissible under emergency Government legislation. The discussion then moved on to the facility itself and related community concerns.
Many of the points raised or questions asked are already addressed elsewhere in this article. The main concerns, which I had mentioned to readers to raise on the night in advance of the meeting included school places, childcare places and healthcare.
A resident from Gandon park said precisely this: “We’ve been waiting ages for services. I’m looking for a commitment that it could be brought up with the minister in terms of services, eg education primary health and childcare…” It was agreed to pass these concerns on.
The flyer from the DCEDIY advertising the information briefing said that: "The Department of Education is planning for the extra school places needed and alternative arrangements will be made to bring occupant children to schools close by where the local school is at capacity. The Department of Health along with the HSE are planning for additional health service requirements". I pointed out that I had written to the Minister for Children and the Minister for Education, had raised with the Adamstown SDZ liaison team and with developers, however there has been no indication as of yet what plans if any will be put in place.
At the briefing meeting there was also mention of two additional teachers being sanctioned in nearby schools, but this won't make a dent with the population of Adamstown increasing rapidly. And bussing Ukrainian children to other towns and leaving parents to struggle for primary school places in Adamstown is not a sustainable option either. The Department needs to get its finger out now and fast-track the school already earmarked.
I reiterated these issues strongly during my own contribution and asked the team presenting promised to revert to the relevant Ministers. I stated again that the school earmarked for Tandy’s Lane in 2026 needs to open earlier and also the Primary Health Care facility.
Some of the other interesting questions raised by residents included surface water attenuation and drainage services (connected to new pipes and systems already in situ), parking on-site (spaces provided), public transport access and issues such as how potential antisocial behaviour will be managed.
It was pointed out that with the four-person family units there were unlikely to be too many issues in this respect, but the OPW said that any related matters would be managed by Tuath Housing and communications links would be set up with local elected representatives.
The cleansing of the road by the contractor was also highlighted as was the potential future need for traffic calming adjacent to the entrance, which is likely a future issue for SDCC, presuming the Celbridge Link Road has already been taken in charge.
All in all it was a constructive evening in terms of its aim of information sharing and receiving feedback. The briefing on the 10th gave us all an opportunity to articulate concerns once again in relation to the provision of services to meet the needs of the Ukrainian community as well as the existing community in Adamstown. The onus is now on the various Government agencies to deliver.
Thank you for taking the time to read this far. I will keep people posted as and when any substantial additional information comes to hand.
Below is a copy of the leaflet about the meeting dropped to the houses "within immediate proximity to this development on Tubber Lane and the Hallwell Estate"
Message for the Ukrainian Community - Послання до української громади - Послание для украинской общины
Ukrainian - До мене звернулися кілька українських сімей із запитом, чи можуть вони розміститися в цьому місці, але, на жаль, Урядовий департамент не дозволяє робити заяви від політиків. «Заявки, подані безпосередньо до DCEDIY для розгляду щодо розподілу, не можуть бути розглянуті, і розподіл не здійснюватиметься на такій основі. Немає можливості для BOTP самостійно подавати заявку або для сторін, щоб агітувати для окремих сімей, яким буде виділено Модульний/швидкобудівний будинок. «Бенефіціари тимчасового захисту мають право вживати власних приватних домовленостей, включаючи потенційне використання заставного житла, якщо вони бажають, і можуть скористатися певною підтримкою для цього. Ті, хто бажає скористатися заставленим житлом у будь-якій місцевості, повинні звернутися до місцевої влади за у цьому районі або в Ірландському Червоному Хресті можна зв’язатися електронною поштою за адресою registerofpledges@redcross.ie або за телефоном 1800 50 70 70. Тож, по суті, немає механізму для сім’ї чи для обраних представників, щоб агітувати за посаду. Це внутрішня оцінка, і у нас немає варіантів. Єдиний кут — через контактний номер Червоного Хреста або спробувати самостійно знайти житло, що, я визнаю, досить складно. Найкраща порада — налагодити зв’язок із місцевою громадою, оскільки іноді є люди, які не хочуть довгострокової комерційної оренди житла, а хочуть, щоб нерухомість була зайнята на рік чи два. Цих людей зазвичай ідентифікують через спілкування в церковних колах, місцевих громадських групах, мистецьких групах тощо. Також сторінки соціальних мереж у Facebook, де шукають і пропонують житло, але це матиме більший попит.
Russian - Со мной связались несколько украинских семей и спросили, можно ли их разместить в этом месте, но, к сожалению, правительственный департамент не разрешает делать заявления от политиков. «Заявки, поданные непосредственно в DCEDIY на рассмотрение вопроса о выделении, не могут быть рассмотрены, и выделения не будут производиться на такой основе. Модульный/быстровозводимый дом. «Получатели временной защиты имеют право принимать собственные частные меры, включая потенциальное использование залогового жилья, если они того пожелают, и могут воспользоваться некоторой поддержкой для этого. Желающие воспользоваться залоговым жильем в любом конкретном районе должны связаться с местными властями в в этом районе или в процессе обещания Ирландского Красного Креста. С Ирландским Красным Крестом можно связаться по электронной почте registerofpledges@redcross.ie или по телефону 1800 50 70 70». Таким образом, по сути, не существует механизма, позволяющего семье или избранным представителям агитировать за должность. Это оценивается внутри страны, и у нас нет вариантов. Единственный вариант — позвонить по контактному номеру Красного Креста или попытаться найти жилье самостоятельно, что, как я признаю, довольно сложно. Лучший совет — поддерживать связь с местным сообществом, поскольку иногда есть люди, которые не хотят долгосрочно арендовать жилье на коммерческой основе, но хотят, чтобы недвижимость была занята на год или два. Этих людей обычно выявляют посредством связей в церковных кругах, местных общественных группах, художественных группах и т. д. Также на страницах в социальных сетях FB, где ищут и предлагают жилье, но это вызовет больший спрос.
English - I have been contacted by a number of Ukrainian families asking if they can be accommodated at this location, but unfortunately the Government Department is not allowing representations to be made from politicians.
"Applications made directly to DCEDIY for consideration for allocation cannot be considered, and allocations will not be made on such a basis. There is no facility for BOTP’s to make an application directly themselves, or for parties to canvass for particular families to be allocated a Modular/Rapid Build home.
"Beneficiaries of Temporary Protection are entitled to make their own private arrangements including potentially availing of pledged accommodation if they wish, and can avail of some supports to do so. Those wishing to avail of pledged accommodation in any given area should contact the Local Authority in that area or the Irish Red Cross pledge process. The Irish Red Cross can be contacted by email at registerofpledges@redcross.ie or by phoning 1800 50 70 70. "
So basically, there's no mechanism for a family or for elected representatives to canvass for a position. It is being assessed internally and we have no options. The only angle is via the Red Cross contact number or to try and source accommodation yourself, which I acknowledge is quite difficult. The best advice is to liaise within the local community as sometimes there are people who don't want long term commercially rented accommodation but want properties occupied for a year or two. These people are usually identified through networking in church circles, local community groups, art groups etc. Also social media FB pages where accommodation is sought and offered, but that would see larger demand.
So basically, there's no mechanism for a family or for elected representatives to canvass for a position. It is being assessed internally and we have no options. The only angle is via the Red Cross contact number or to try and source accommodation yourself, which I acknowledge is quite difficult. The best advice is to liaise within the local community as sometimes there are people who don't want long term commercially rented accommodation but want properties occupied for a year or two. These people are usually identified through networking in church circles, local community groups, art groups etc. Also social media FB pages where accommodation is sought and offered, but that would see larger demand.
Kommentare